Romantasy, the fantasy-romance hybrid that fills bestseller tables, is much older than its label. In a Guardian essay published on 18 October, the genre is traced back to the courts of late twelfth-century France, where fairy romances were hugely popular and spread across Europe and down the social scale.
Is romantasy really a medieval genre?
The Guardian piece argues that modern titles such as A Court of Thorns and Roses belong to a centuries-old tradition. Medieval romances, it says, drew on earlier fairy myths, especially in Arthurian legend, and were adapted to be as thrilling as possible. The ingredients will sound familiar to any current reader: crystal palaces, perilous enchanted realms, fairy knights and queens living in unearthly splendour.
Scholars have long treated the motif as central. The Cambridge University Press chapter Fairy Lovers: Sexuality, Order and Narrative in Medieval Romance describes the fairy mistress who offers herself to a human hero as one of the best-known motifs of medieval romance, and notes that Chaucer's parody Sir Thopas shows how familiar it was to audiences.
What does Lanval tell us?
The twelfth-century poem Lanval is the Guardian's key example. It follows a penniless, overlooked knight who is rescued more than once by his beloved fairy queen and who ends the story riding away with her to fairyland. Medievalists.net describes Marie de France's Lanval as one of several short romances she wrote, work that was known at the court of Henry II. The point for modern readers is the reversal: in many of these stories the powerful figure doing the rescuing is the fairy queen, not the knight.
| Work | Period or setting | Link to romantasy |
|---|---|---|
| Lanval | Twelfth century | Fairy queen repeatedly rescues a knight |
| Sir Thopas | Chaucer's parody | Knight seeks an elf queen; mocks the genre |
| A Court of Thorns and Roses | Modern bestseller | Cited as part of the same heritage |
Why has the genre always attracted ridicule?
The Guardian essay notes that Chaucer himself wrote a parody, Sir Thopas, about a knight in search of an elf queen. It argues that today's dismissal of romantasy as fluff echoes that old mockery, and that the scorn owes much to the fact that the genre is read and written largely by women. It also cites a report that 18% of romantasy readers in the United States are men, a reminder that the audience is wider than the stereotype.
For the reader: where to begin
If this has made you curious, there are two easy routes. Start with a modern romantasy you already own and look for the medieval pattern: a fairy ruler, an enchanted realm, a mortal who is changed by the meeting. Or read Lanval in a modern translation; it is short enough for one sitting. Browse the Pulse hub for more book coverage.
What should we take from it?
Genres are rarely as new as they look. The Guardian's argument is not that a twelfth-century poem and a current bestseller are the same, but that the same appetite for escape, enchantment and stories led by powerful women has been served for nine hundred years, and mocked for just as long.
Frequently asked questions
Is romantasy a new genre?
The term is modern, but the Guardian argues the genre has medieval roots in twelfth-century fairy romances.
What is a good medieval text to start with?
Lanval, a short twelfth-century poem attributed to Marie de France, is a compact entry point.
Editorial desk
Stories signed by the Cultvia editorial desk follow our editorial policy; every story lists its sources at the end and errors are fixed under our corrections policy.
Last updated:
What changed?
- : First published
Sources
- Medieval romance overflowed with sexually active fairies: the surprisingly long roots of romantasy — The Guardian, 18 October 2026
- Fairy Lovers: Sexuality, Order and Narrative in Medieval Romance — Cambridge University Press, 1 January 2013
- Medieval Fairy Tales — Medievalists.net, 1 November 2020