A US appeals panel has ruled that medical drama The Pitt is similar enough to ER for a lawsuit over it to go to a jury trial. BBC News reports that the case, brought by the widow of ER creator Michael Crichton, will now be heard in Los Angeles Superior Court. Warner Bros had called the suit "baseless" and asked for it to be dismissed.
What is the lawsuit claiming?
Sherri Crichton and the John Michael Crichton Trust argue that The Pitt is effectively an uncredited reboot of ER. They say Michael Crichton's contract included a "frozen rights" provision barring spin-offs, sequels or reboots without his express consent. According to the BBC, talks about an ER reboot began in 2020 and collapsed over credit and financial guarantees, after which producers developed The Pitt instead. The family says producers "simply moved the show from Chicago to Pittsburgh" and rebranded it.
What did the judges decide?
| Point | What was reported |
|---|---|
| Court | Three-judge panel; case proceeds to jury trial in Los Angeles Superior Court |
| Similarities cited | Emergency room setting, fast pace, medical jargon, graphic injuries, young doctors being trained |
| Test applied | Details "suffice for a prima facie case" |
| Claims dismissed | Separate claims against Noah Wyle, John Wells and R Scott Gemmill, for insufficient evidence they knew they might be violating contractual rights |
Beyazperde's report says the court rejected the studio's bid to dismiss the case and quotes Sherri Crichton as saying the case matters for all writers and creators protecting their intellectual property. The ruling is a decision to let the case proceed; it is not a finding that The Pitt infringed anything.
What happens next, and where can you watch?
The Pitt, which stars Noah Wyle and first aired in 2025, is a HBO Max series. ER ran for 331 episodes from 1994 and won 23 Emmy Awards, according to the BBC. No trial date was given in the sources, so readers should expect pre-trial evidence and witness stages first. More series news is in Pulse.
Frequently asked questions
Has The Pitt been found to infringe ER?
No. The court only ruled the similarities suffice for the case to proceed to a jury trial.
Where will the case be heard?
Los Angeles Superior Court, before a jury.
Editorial desk
Stories signed by the Cultvia editorial desk follow our editorial policy; every story lists its sources at the end and errors are fixed under our corrections policy.
Last updated:
What changed?
- : First published
Sources
- The Pitt and ER are similar enough for lawsuit to proceed, judge rules — BBC News, 5 November 2026
- The Pitt'e ER'dan telif davası: iki dizi jüri karşısına çıkıyor — Beyazperde, 5 November 2026